論文・プリプリント

閉じすぎるシステムの危険:最適化と人工的主権

科学理論、AI最適化、制度が暫定的な枠組みを最終解として扱うと、修正可能性が失われ、システムが脆弱になると論じます。評価、責任、主権を最適化プロセスの内部へ完全に閉じ込めず、人間が再検討できる参照点を残すLighthouse Principleを提案します。

日本語解説

科学理論、AI最適化、制度が暫定的な枠組みを最終解として扱うと、修正可能性が失われ、システムが脆弱になると論じます。評価、責任、主権を最適化プロセスの内部へ完全に閉じ込めず、人間が再検討できる参照点を残すLighthouse Principleを提案します。

この研究の位置づけ

文明・制度設計に関する規範的な構造分析です。単独で政策効果を実証するものではありません。

原題: The Risk of Closure: Why Discovery, Optimization, and Artificial Sovereignty Can Destabilize Civilizational Evolution


English Original / 英語原文

Files https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18663778

Authors/Creators

Description

This paper presents a structural analysis of closure as a failure mode in scientific, computational, and civilizational systems. It examines how dynamical completeness in formal systems does not entail empirical or institutional finality, and identifies a recurrent vulnerability arising when provisional frameworks are treated as final.

Building on a distinction between dynamical description and post-dynamical selection, the work clarifies the structural boundary between admissible possibility and realized historical constraint. It argues that attempts to internalize evaluation, responsibility, or sovereignty entirely within optimization processes introduce systemic fragility by eliminating revisability.

The paper introduces the Lighthouse Principle as a civilizational design constraint: no evaluative framework should be treated as structurally final. This principle preserves adaptive capacity by maintaining the institutional and epistemic conditions necessary for revision and re-observation.

This work does not propose new physical laws or empirical predictions. Its scope is structural and conceptual, focusing on the limits of formal description and the implications for artificial intelligence governance, optimization systems, and long-term civilizational stability.